Reprinted with permission of The Governance Institute, San Diego, CA, (2021)
The COVID-19 pandemic is far from over, yet there are signs of hope
and optimism with increasing vaccine rates, decreasing case rates, and
declining deaths. As pediatric institutions enter into a new phase of the pandemic
response, including stabilizing operations and reevaluating strategy, it is also the
time to start planning for the next unknown. As daunting as it may sound, boards
should leverage the lessons learned and innovations born from this pandemic to
begin preparing for the next crisis. Whether the next unknown is another global health
event, significant cuts to Medicaid or other funding sources, a local or widespread
natural disaster, or a disruptive cyber-attack, the board has a key role to ensure it and
the organization are prepared.
Pediatric hospitals and health systems are indispensable community assets and
directors have an obligation to ensure the mission is carried out despite any challenge
or crisis the institution may face. Looking forward, through a renewed lens of
preparedness, governing bodies should be asking and continually answering three
What Are the Risks and How Will We Mitigate Them?
Boards must understand key enterprise risks and the associated mitigation strategies.
Hospital and health system leadership teams should identify and communicate
strategic and operational threats on an ongoing basis. Educating directors on these
risk points enables the board to carry out its fiduciary role.
The board should review and endorse key organizational plans on a regular
basis, including enterprise risk assessments, business continuity plans, disaster
management plans, and financial crisis plans. Board committees, such as quality, finance, and audit, should be well versed in the elements of those plans related to
their charter. There is also opportunity for directors to be involved in crisis planning by
sharing ideas and insights from other industries and participating in disaster planning
exercises. When board members are knowledgeable about potential risks and are
aligned with the leadership team on mitigation plans, there are fewer surprises when a
crisis occurs. Continuous readiness allows the leadership team to focus on executing
mitigation plans and allows the board to support and engage as needed.
Who Will Lead Us?
Strong leadership, at every level, has been essential in navigating the COVID-19
crisis—within every patient unit, throughout the C-suite, and in the boardroom. As
boards prepare for the future, succession planning and crisis leadership planning are
more critical than ever before.
While boards have the core responsibility of hiring the CEO and monitoring
performance, formal succession planning is often lacking in rigor and limited to the CEO position. Boards tend to be prepared when a CEO is approaching a planned
retirement, yet leadership succession needs can arise unexpectedly, creating an
unplanned gap. Boards should thoughtfully review succession plans for the CEO and
other key executive roles at least annually, through a broadened lens of the skills and
attributes needed to lead through a crisis.
Succession planning is not only important for the executive team, but also for board
leadership. The selection of the hospital or health system board chair is one of the
most critical decisions a CEO and board makes. For planning purposes, boards must
assume there will be a crisis at some point during the board chair’s term. Identifying a
board leader who has deep knowledge of the organization, a commitment of time and
attention, and the ability to make challenging decisions quickly will require intentional
board leadership succession planning. In doing so, boards should maximize a chair-elect position to enable mentoring and a smooth transition of leadership.
Boards should have visibility into crisis leadership plans, including an outlined chain
of command to ensure continuity and critical decision making when key roles may be
unavailable during a crisis. For example, if the CEO is personally impacted and unable
to make decisions, who will serve in that capacity? This planning is equally important
for the board. If the board chair becomes unable to lead during a crisis for any reason,
a clear and pre-determined plan should be in place to carry out those duties.
Where Can I Lend My Voice and Hands?
The COVID-19 crisis highlighted the power of board engagement and advocacy
throughout pediatric hospitals. During this time, directors led philanthropic relief
efforts, coordinated community partnerships to bolster critical supply shortages, and
advocated at the state and federal level for pediatric hospital funding. Board members
should intentionally seek ways to engage with the organization and to advocate
on behalf of kids and pediatric institutions on an ongoing basis. As there is never a
shortage of opportunities, directors can simply ask the leadership team “how can I
help?” Help comes in many forms. For instance, directors can facilitate knowledge
sharing opportunities between their own organization and the hospital. Connecting
the cyber security leader from another industry with the IT leader at the hospital, for
example, leads to shared learning and deeper organizational relationships. In addition,
board members should share their personal story of commitment to the institution
and the importance of specialized pediatric care in the region at every opportunity.
Awareness and support grow one story at a time. When board members consistently engage with the institution beyond the boardroom and use their voices to advocate for
kids, they are more prepared to support when a crisis arises.
The board’s role in supporting organizational resilience cannot be overstated.
Throughout the pandemic, boards have witnessed weary management teams along
with exhausted providers and staff carrying out heroic efforts. As simple as it may
seem, a “thank you” and acknowledgement of the hard work of the leadership team
and staff coming directly from a board member can boost morale during times
of crisis and calm. Boards must maintain a focus on resiliency moving forward,
understand where the stress points are, and support the leadership team’s efforts to
enhance well-being across the organization.
The incredible innovations born out of the COVID-19 crisis must be celebrated.
Countless aspects of patient care delivery, organizational culture, and community
connection have been forever improved. Boards have an opportunity to harness
the lessons learned from COVID-19 and the energy of innovation to prepare for the
next unknown. Preparing for the next unknown is an ongoing process. Boards and
leadership teams can use these three questions to facilitate an ongoing dialogue so
that when a crisis presents, board members are knowledgeable and ready to support.
Key Board Takeaways
Children’s hospital and health system boards should leverage the lessons
learned and innovations born from the COVID-19 pandemic to prepare for the
next unknown. Going forward, it is imperative for boards to:
- Understand significant organizational risks and associated mitigation
- Review key plans on a regular basis, including enterprise risk assessments,
business continuity plans, disaster management plans, and financial crisis
- Engage in ongoing succession planning for key executives and board
- Have visibility into crisis leadership plans for executive and board leadership.
- Continually engage with the institution inside and outside of the boardroom
and learn how to best advocate on behalf of kids and families.
- Maintain a heightened focus on resiliency, understand where the stress
points are, and support the leadership team’s efforts to enhance well-being
across the organization.